Quantcast

Ahoy, there!

Muggle-Born.net is a (mostly) young adult book review blog run by Cialina.

I am NOT currently accepting review requests. For more on my review policy and rating system, click here.

Recent Reviews

Connect

GoodReadsTwitterFacebookYouTubeRSS

You are here: Home » Book Review » Three Stars » Book Review: A Countess Below Stairs by Eva Ibbotson

A COUNTESS BELOW STAIRS by Eva Ibbotson
Publication Date: May 10th 2007 by Puffin
Rating:

Summary: After the Russian revolution turns her world topsy-turvy, Anna, a young Russian countess, has no choice but to flee to England. Penniless, Anna hides her aristocratic background and takes a job as servant in the household of the esteemed Westerholme family, armed only with an outdated housekeeping manual and sheer determination. Desperate to keep her past a secret, Anna is nearly overwhelmed by her new duties—not to mention her instant attraction to Rupert, the handsome Earl of Westerholme. To make matters worse, Rupert appears to be falling for her as well. As their attraction grows stronger, Anna finds it more and more difficult to keep her most dearly held secrets from unraveling. And then there’s the small matter of Rupert’s beautiful and nasty fiancée…

Review Overview:

  • Romance lacks passion
  • Full of vibrant and fun characters
  • Storyline is very similar to Ibbotson’s THE RELUCTANT HEIRESS

If you’ve read THE RELUCTANT HEIRESS by Eva Ibbotson, the formula for A COUNTESS BELOW STAIRS is pretty much the same thing: royal in disguise, nasty fiancee who wants everything her way, servants who adore the female protagonist… everything down to the plot is similar with the exception that this was set in a different country. Just after reading THE RELUCTANT HEIRESS the story line was completely predictable. I’m afraid to think that Ibbotson’s books are all like this, following a similar formula.

Formula and similarities aside, I still did enjoy reading this book. Anna is a fun lovable character and I sympathized with her character from the very beginning.  A COUNTESS BELOW STAIRS is filled with other magnificent characters that I instantly loved from Miss Ollie to Petya.

Ibbotson is a phenomenal storyteller but she skirts away from telling the romance from Anna or Rupert’s perspective. As the reader, I never got a clear insight of their feelings. It makes me feel like a spectator of their romance as if I was the Rupert’s mother the dowager countess or one of the servants. While I can feel that they are in love, I don’t know the depth of their love because of the character’s failure to connect truly with the reader.This factor is a big reason why I don’t love Ibbotson’s books as much as I wish I did. The stories she tells are inspiring and heartwarming, but the romance fails to affect me emotionally.

A COUNTESS BELOW STAIRS is a nicely paced historical read. Ibbotson writes beautifully, but if you are looking for a passionate romance, I wouldn’t recommend her books.



Comments 3 comments

Permalink Permalink Category Book Review, Three Stars - , , , , , | Words 579 words



3 Responses to “Book Review: A Countess Below Stairs by Eva Ibbotson”

  • Small Review says:

    It’s funny that you mention the romance lacking a connection to the reader. I haven’t read any of this author’s books yet, mostly because I get the vague impression that they’re written at a distance, if you know what I mean? I feel like I may have trouble reaching characters’ deeper emotions. I have no idea why, but it seems like that feeling lines up with what you’re saying about the romance.

    It’s a shame the plot of this was so close to the other book. I’ll keep that in mind and try to read them very spaced out. Thank you!

    • Cialina says:

      Yes! I know exactly what you mean…. I got the sense of what they were feeling based on what others perceived of them, but I never really got to know the characters’ relationship intimately.

  • Small Review says:

    I find that very frustrating. I’m having trouble with the main character in one of the books I’m reading now. I feel like I know what she’s doing, but never what she’s really feeling. I’m not “in her head” as much as I’d like to be.

  • It has always been forever, for me, Sassenach.
    - Diana Gabaldon, Voyager


    Subscribe to Blog via Email

    Join 28 other subscribers

    Currently Reading

    Four Nights With the Duke (Desperate Duchesses by the Numbers, #2; Desperate Duchesses, #8) by Eloisa James
    Four Nights With the Duke (Desperate Duchesses by the Numbers, #2; Desperate Duchesses, #8) by Eloisa James

    Browse by Category

    Browse by Tag

    Archives

    Advertise

    10% Discount / APMA12 Coupon Code / Book Depository

    Link Muggle-Born

    Muggle-Born
    <a href="http://muggle-born.net/" target="_blank"><img src="http://i46.tinypic.com/168szk1.png" border="0" alt="Muggle-Born"></a>

    More Buttons Here

    Search Engine Optimization